foolish federalism

From the Richmond Daily Dispatch July 21, 1864:

An inevitable fate.

One of the favorite bugbears kept by the United States press before the people, to stimulate their energies in support of the invasion, is the dread of future internal convulsions and civil wars if this revolution is successful. It is an appeal to the fears of the masses, as well as to all the interests involved in law and order, and has no doubt exerted great influence in keeping the whole North resolute and persevering at its work.

But there never was a more shallow fallacy. War is the inevitable lot of humanity — civil as well as foreign war. Both have been the fate of every country of the world, and of democracies more than by other forms of government. Probably Prussia enjoys more internal stability than any other nation; because Prussia possesses the remarkable combination of a despotism controlled by public opinion, which public opinion is sustained by a citizen soldiery, who, in organization and military efficiency, are fully equal to her regular army, and vastly superior to it in numbers. If the North can adopt such a government, it may enjoy its immunities from civil convulsions; but, to do this, it must wade, for this generation, through a sea of blood which we hardly expect such a self-indulgent generation to encounter for the benefit of posterity. A wild democracy cannot be converted into a despotism, and the State Rights peculiarity of the United States Constitution exchanged for a formal consolidation, without scenes of strife and carnage, compared with which the horrors of this contest are mere child’s play.

The Constitution of the old United States, which theoretically was the essence of human wisdom, has proved practically the climax of human absurdity. Never before was there a Constitution which left the citizens in doubt to whom supreme allegiance was due.–This Constitution calls upon its people to serve two masters, the General Government and the States, and to serve two masters is as impossible for a nation as an individual. In addition to this seed of civil convulsions, sown in the very heart of the organic law, the democratic institutions of every State contain in themselves the prolific germs of everlasting faction and blood. The experience of universal history is uniform to that effect. No Democracy was ever permanent, and the United States, as it has fully proved during this war, are no wiser and no better than those who have before tried the same experiment. …

Their only hope, indeed, is to accept the separation of the old Union as an accomplished fact, to withdraw their invading armies, to moderate their inordinate ambition and vanity, and to consent event to a peaceful division of the Northwest and New England, rather than seek to compel the adhesion of such incongruous elements. Such a gigantic territory as that they seek to control, and such a dissimilar population, cannot be held together by anything but a gigantic despotism, and even that will not ensure permanent order and quiet. Three Republics are not too many for the area and numbers of the old United States. The balance of power could be preserved, and internal affairs more harmoniously directed by three than by two. That result will have to come some day, and it offers the only mitigation of the evils that are in store for the United States.

Alas, the Confederate Constitution also divvied up power between the central government and the states.

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Week, Confederate States of America, Southern Society | Tagged , | Leave a comment

raise ya 200,000

I kinda felt like I was at a card table with the most vigorous prosecutors of the war.

From The Papers And Writings Of Abraham Lincoln, Volume Seven:

TELEGRAM TO GENERAL U.S. GRANT.
EXECUTIVE MANSION, WASHINGTON, July 20, 1864. 4.30 p.m.

LIEUTENANT-GENERAL GRANT, City Point, Va.:

Yours of yesterday, about a call for three hundred thousand, is received. I suppose you had not seen the call for five hundred thousand, made the day before, and which, I suppose, covers the case. Always glad to have your suggestions.

A. LINCOLN.

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Week, Lincoln Administration, Military Matters, Northern Politics During War, Northern Society | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

strength and peace

The twin sisters liberty and union (Entered . . . 1863 by C.S. Allen & Co. Segar Manrs.; LOC: LC-USZ62-90679)

A. Lincoln: for all

150 years ago today President Lincoln called for 500,000 more troops – volunteers to be supplemented by a draft to fill quotas. He also seemed to be encouraging peace missions – as long as the terms were restoration of the Union and the extermination of slavery:

From The Papers And Writings Of Abraham Lincoln, Volume Seven:

ANNOUNCEMENT CONCERNING TERMS OF PEACE.
EXECUTIVE MANSION,

WASHINGTON, July 18, 1864.

TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN:

Any proposition which embraces the restoration of peace, the integrity of the whole Union, and the abandonment of slavery, and which comes by and with an authority that can control the armies now at war against the United States, will be received and considered by the Executive Government of the United States, and will be met by liberal terms on other substantial and collateral points; and the bearer or bearers thereof shall have safe conduct both ways.

A. LINCOLN.

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Week, Lincoln Administration, Military Matters, Northern Politics During War, Northern Society | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

convalescing

A ward in hospital at convalescent camp near Alexandria, Va. (photographed July, 1864, printed between 1880 and 1889; LOC: LC-DIG-ppmsca-33646)

“A ward in hospital at convalescent camp near Alexandria, Va.” (July 1864)

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Month, Military Matters | Tagged | Leave a comment

Little Mac’s chances

[Civil War envelope showing portrait of Major General George B. McClellan inset in medallion decorated with eagle and American flags] (between 1861 and 1865; LOC: LC-DIG-ppmsca-34635)

wrapping himself in “our grand old flag”?

A Southern publication succinctly rated the odds of George B. McClellan winning the 1864 presidential election.

From the Richmond Daily Dispatch July 16, 1864:

McClellan on the old flag.

–McClellan, who stands about as much chance for succeeding Lincoln in the Presidential chair as he did of taking Richmond, is playing the “old flag” dodge to further his prospects. In his address at West Point he said:

Battle monument, U.S. Military Academy (c.1901; LOC: LC-DIG-ppmsca-18158)

“Battle monument, U.S. Military Academy” (c.1901)

Rebellion against a Government like ours, which contains the means of self-adjustment, and a pacific remedy for evils, should never be confounded with a revolution against despotic power which refuses redress of wrongs. Such a rebellion cannot be justified upon ethical grounds, and the only alternatives for our choice are its suppression or the destruction of our nationality. At such a time as this, and in such a struggle, political partisanship should be merged into a pure and brave patriotism, which thinks only of the good of the whole country. It was in this cause and with these motives that so many of our comrades have given up their lives and in this we are all personally pledged in all honor and fidelity. Shall such devotion as that of our dead comrades be of no avail. Shall it be said in after ages that we lacked the vigor to complete the work thus begun? That after all these noble lives freely given, we hesitated and failed to keep straight on until our land was saved? Forbid it, Heaven! and give us firmer, truce [truer] hearts than that. Oh, spirits of the valiant dead, souls of our slain heroes, lend us year [your] own indomitable will, and if it be permitted you to commune with those still chained by the trammels of mortality, hover around us in the midst of danger and tribulation — cheer the firm, strengthen the weak, that none may doubt the salvation of the Republic and the triumph of our grand old flag.

This excerpt is from a much longer speech General McClellan delivered at West Point on June 15, 1864 at the dedication of the ground chosen for a Civil War battle monument to commemorate the regular army soldiers who were killed during the war. You can read all about it at The New-York Times. The monument itself was not dedicated until 1897.

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Week, Confederate States of America, Northern Politics During War, The election of 1864 | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

invasion digest

NY Times 7-11-1864

Stanton to Dix on Monocacy: “our troops behaved well, but suffered severe loss.”


A Democrat paper recapped Jubal Early’s July invasion. Lee had Grant stymied at Petersburg, so the Confederate force could drive north and achieve some well-defined objectives. By the time this article was published the rebels had already recrossed the Potomac.

From a Seneca County, New York newspaper in July 1864:

The Rebel Invasion.

For the past ten days the news has been of a very exciting character. A most formidable rebel invasion has created no little alarm for the safety of the Federal Capital. The force that entered Maryland have apparently succeeded in obtaining what they were in pursuit of, and returned in good order. The telegraph now assures us that Washington is safe! This is most encouraging news.

The retreat of Gen. HUNTER from Lynchburg into Western Virginia, was a most fortunate circumstance for the Confederate forces. LEE no longer considering Richmond in danger of GRANT’s army, sent a force of from 15,000 to 20,000 up the Shenandoah Valley, for a threefold object. In the first place, to secure crops in the Valley, now reaped and stacked; in the second place, to capture all the cattle and supplies he could in Maryland, as well as to destroy the railroads; and in the third place, to alarm the Federal Government so as to compel the withdrawal of forces from Gen. GRANT to protect Washington and Baltimore. In these several objects he has been eminently successful. Over three millions of dollars worth of stores, it is stated, were captured at Martinsburg. On Saturday last a severe engagement took place at Monocacy, Md., lasting nearly all day, and ending in the repulse of our forces. The Secretary of War says we lost “heavily.” Our men falling back to Baltimore, gave the enemy full sway, and he certainly improved it. For several days all railroad and telegraphic communications was cut with Baltimore and Washington, and but for the timely aid rendered by the forces from Grant’s army, Washington would, undoubtedly, have fallen into rebel hands. It is stated that the 2d, 5th and 18 Army Corps were sent from Grant to Washington.

The news this morning is that the enemy after capturing all the horses, cattle and supplies in the vicinity of Baltimore and Washington, have safely re-crossed the Potomac, and are now encamped at Silver Springs, some 20,000 to 30,000 strong. – Thus ends the great rebel raid, which has so alarmed the country for the past few days.

[Memorial] "Lincoln under fire at Fort Stevens" (by Harris & Ewing, between 1915 and 1923; LOC: LC-DIG-hec-30172)

memorializing “Lincoln under fire at Fort Stevens” (photo between 1920 and 1923)

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Week, Military Matters | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

“natal day” blues

SENECA reported that the Union army got pushed out of the Shenandoah Valley again. On July 4th his New York 1st Veteran Cavalry was crossing the Potomac – in retreat, pursued by the rebels.

From a Seneca County, New York newspaper in 1864:

From the Veteran Cavalry.

PLEASANT VALLEY, NEAR MARYLAND
HEIGHT, July 8th, 1864.

FRIEND STOWELL: – Once more the Union Army is driven from the Shenandoah and again the rebel hordes trample the soil of “my Maryland.” A long and hitherto remarkably successful campaign is suddenly brought to an unhappy close and the victories and glories of the Army of the Shenandoah are obscured by disaster and defeat.

After long and weary marches, skirmishing by night and fighting by day, we are at last at the famous Maryland Heights, pretty nearly surrounded to be sure, but confident of being able to hold out until reinforcements can arrive, hoping soon to hurl back the invader and drive these saucy rebels into Virginia again.

Somebody is responsible for all this, but without saying who, let me state a few facts concerning their unfortunate termination of the campaign in Western Virginia, and give some account of the part the Veterans have taken in it.On the 25th of June an an immense wagon train with ammunition and supplies for Gen. Hunter, left Martinsburg accompanied by a strong escort of Cavalry, Infantry and Artillery. The 1st Cavalry Brigade consisting of the 1st N.Y. Veterans, the 21st N.Y. Cavalry and detachments from the 15th N.Y. [,] 1st Md. and 22nd Pa., all under command of Col. J.S. Platner, took the advance.

We had not gone far, however, before strange rumors concerning Hunter, reports of disaster and defeat, began to come in, together with stories of rebel armies moving down the Valley. Consequently the train was halted and Col. Platner sent with his Brigade to Winchester, but no enemy could be found [,] although the reports of a rebel advance in force grew thicker and more reliable every day.

Ere long news of Hunter’s whereabout [sic], was received and the expedition being thus rendered unnecessary, the train returned while the cavalry and a small part of the Infantry was left to check any advance the enemy might make down the Valley. The Veterans were ordered to a small place on our left called Smithfield, while the rest of the Brigade held the Winchester Pike at Bunker Hill, ten miles from Martinsburg.

On the 29th ult., Mosby made a raid upon the Baltimore and Ohio R.R. to the left of Smithfield, and of course the whole cavalry force was ordered out after him, and of course didn’t catch him.

Next day our whole line fell back and took up a new position three miles nearer Martinsburg.

On Friday, July 1st, our scouts reported the rebels in force at Winchester, but this did not seem to be believed at Martinsburg [,] where Gen’s. Sigel and Stahl both had their Headquarters. On Saturday our scouting parties had a skirmish with the rebel advance, one mile this side of Winchester, yet on Sunday morning, strange as it may seem, Col. Platner received orders to march to Winchester and attack the enemy. Ten minutes after this order was received, the enemy opened on our pickets.

We had been expecting an attack all night, our horses were saddled and ready to mount, so in a few moments the 1st Brigade was at work. The fight commenced at six o’clock and at eight A.M., Col. P. had driven the enemy back three miles. While this was going on immediately in front, an attack was also made upon our left at Leetown, where Col. Mulligan of Lexington notoriety was posted with two regiments of Infantry and one section of Artillery with the 1st Veterans thrown out in his front. After a very short fight Mulligan retreated to Shepardstown, where the Cavalry made another stand and repulsed the enemy.

At 10 A.M., the rebels having been largely reinforced, made an attack upon us with at least two thousand cavalry and Infantry and a Battery of Artillery. We had bu[t] six hundred fighting men left in the Brigade, including 100 men sent up to reinforce us, but Col. Platner fought them until noon, when we fell back to Martinsburg in obedience to an order received from Gen. Stahl. The enemy closely pursued us, skirmishing all the way and we even had a cavalry charge in the streets of Martinsburg. There were many splendid Cavalry charges made while we were falling back, but the boldest dash of all was made by Capt. McNulty of the 21st N.Y., who charged the rebel advance and drove them clear back upon their Artillery.

upperpotomac by Robert knox Sneden (LOC: http://www.loc.gov/item/gvhs01.vhs00045/)

crossed the Potomac at Shepardstown on the 4th

When we reached Martinsburg, we found the whole army had gone, Generals and all, and we were ordered to cover their retreat to the Potomac at Shepardstown, which we did, crossing the river at sunrise on the morning of the Fourth of July. – And as the bells in many a northern village were ringing forth a joyous welcome to our country’s natal day, and you all at home were beginning to “celebrate,” we were slowly retreating before a victorious foe stopping now and then to check his advance and then falling suddenly back again. On we marched, passing through Sharpsburg, a place well remembered well remembered by many a Veteran of the “Old 33d,” falling back through Pleasant Valley until we again struck the Potomac, this time on the eastern side of Maryland heights, where we rested for the night, lying down in the road, holding our horses by the bridle as we slept.

The enemy now attacked Maryland Heights from the western side, captured Bolivar Heights, a very strong position, and occupied Harper’s Ferry almost without resistance, advanced their Infantry but were unable to get their Artillery in position to do much harm.

On Tuesday the Brigade went to Knoxville, up the Pike toward Frederick City, and then down toward Point of Rocks, but finding the country clear returned to Pleasant Valley. Next day we crossed Maryland Heights at Solomon’s Gap and attacked the left flank of the enemy, had a “right smart skirmish” and returned to our original position.

By this time our Brigade had become well nigh exhausted. Ten days of incessant marching and skirmishing, with only now and then an hour’s rest, without sleep and all this in the midst of a drought unprecedented in this section, began to tell upon the horses and men of the command. On Wednesday night however, we rested, the first rest since we left Bunker Hill, Va. But on Thursday morning the rebels advanced down Pleasant Valley and at them we went again. Two days more of fighting and we have driven them out and to-night all is quiet.

2010-09-02-Harpers-Ferry-From-Maryland-Heights-Panorama-Crop

Harper’s Ferry from Maryland Heights 146 years later

The rebels are now burning the Quartermasters and commissary stores at Harper’s Ferry and are said to be retreating.

SATURDAY, July 9, 1864.

All is quiet this morning. The enemy has gone but which way is not yet certainly known. Gens. Sigel and Stahl are off too, having been superseded in command here by Gen. Howe. We expect to leave to day in pursuit of the foe. It is impossible to tell yet what our losses have been during the past week, put [sic] they are pretty heavy. All that I have heard of from Seneca Falls are Corporal Luther Waldo and private Nicholas Christy, both shot in the thigh. – Christy is wounded severely. Lt. Bacon is in command of company K just now, the 1st Lieut. being Adjutant General of the brigade. Many of the officers and men are completely worn out. I will send you a list of casualties in our regiment as soon as I can obtain one. Yours ever,

SENECA.

Mark Fickett’s 2010 photo of harper’s Ferry is licensed by Creative Commons

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Month, Military Matters | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

disloyalty?

From the Richmond Daily Dispatch July 12, 1864:

Local matters.

Application for a discharge from military service.

–Through his counsel, Hon. James Lyons and Gen. Geo. W. Randolph, R. D’Orsey Ogden, manager of the Richmond Theatre, made an application under a writ of habeas corpus before Judge Halyburton yesterday for a discharge from military service.–The ground upon which he claims exemption is that of being a British subject. It was ordered by the Judge that the writ be issued, returnable on Thursday.

Trial postponed.

–In the Confederate States District Court yesterday, Judge Halyburton presiding, the trial of Mrs. Caroline Alian, indicted for using disloyal language in certain letters which she is charged with having written to persons at the North, was postponed till the August term of the Court, and the accused was thereupon admitted to bail for her appearance in the sum of $100,000–This makes the fourth or fifth time that Mrs. A’s case has been put off.

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Week, Military Matters, Southern Society | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

conscientious objector?

Life could be dangerous for an enrolling officer, even if he was armed and had guards.

Richmond area 1864 (LOC: http://www.loc.gov/item/99439129/)

enrolling officer’s office in Manchester (map published 1864)

From the Richmond Daily Dispatch July 11, 1864:

Local matters.
Attempt to murder an enrolling officer.

–On Thursday last an attempt was made to murder Lieutenant Spencer Hancock, of Manchester, one of the enrolling officers for the third Congressional district, by a man named William G. Burton, residing in Chesterfield county, about eight miles from this city. Burton, who is a conscript, was sent for by Lieut. Hancock, to know the reason why he had not reported, but the guard finding him absent from home left word with his wife that he must report to the enrolling office in Manchester as soon as he returned. This was on the 5th instant, and on the 7th he drove up to Hancock’s office in Manchester, and in a very menacing manner demanded to know why he had been sent for.–Lieut. H., who was alone, replied that he only wished to know why he had not reported for military duty, and if he claimed exemption it was necessary to see the papers entitling him thereto. To this Burton got into a towering rage, swore he would not report to any man, nor would he go into the service, and then started towards the door, declaring his intention to return home.–Hancock then informed him that he was under arrest and placed himself between B. and the door; but he being a powerful man, it was a very easy matter to toss the obstruction out of the way. Hancock then ordered the guard to seize him, and at the same time drew his pistol in order to check the advances which B. was making upon him, the butt end of which he was compelled to use several times upon his head before it was possible to subdue and confine him. The physical strength of Burton was so great that it required the combined efforts of four men to effect his arrest, and while in their embrace he made repeated lunges at Lieut. H., each time dragging them some distance after him. Burton was then confined and taken before the Examining Board at Camp Lee, but learning the facts of his resistance he was ordered by the Board to be taken to Castle Thunder. Subsequently Lieut. Hancock was directed to take Burton before the Military Court Martial of Gen. Lee’s army, which was in session at Chesterfield Court House. While on the way, on foot, under a guard of two men, he seemed very penitent, confessed that he had done wrong, that Hancock had served him perfectly right, and begged that he would make it as easy with him as possible. Arriving at the first water station, in advance of the train, Lieut. H. being very feeble from sickness, determined to take the cars the balance of the way. –They then sat down on the side of the road to wait for the train, Burton (handcuffed) sitting between the two guards and Hancock a yard or two off. In a short while Lieut. H. fell asleep, but had not been so many minutes before B. sprang to his feet, jumped over the guard, and first striking him on the head with both hands and the iron cuffs, attempted to plant both heels of his boots in his forehead. Fortunately, however, the blow from B.’s fists partially turned H.’s head to one side, and the desperado’s designs were thereby thwarted in part. As it was, however, his injuries were very severe, as one of the heels of B.’s boots struck H. on the side of the head, severely stunning him and cutting his head in a shocking manner. Burton is a man weighing over two hundred pounds, and had he have jumped fairly on H.’s head, there is little doubt but it would have been crushed in. The prisoner was committed to Castle Thunder on Friday morning.

Lieutenant Hancock’s injuries are of a serious character internally, and yesterday afternoon he was suffering much from a stamp which Burton gave him in the breast.

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Week, Military Matters, Southern Society | Tagged | Leave a comment

pump for patients

City Point, Va. Tents of the general hospital ( 1864 October; LOC: LC-DIG-cwpb-03872)

“City Point, Va. Tents of the general hospital” (October 1864)

From the Richmond Daily Dispatch July 9, 1864:

Additional from the North.

From Northern papers; of the 4th inst, we gather a variety of interesting intelligence, which we condense in the summary below: …

With the consent of Gen Grant, the Christian Commission has sent to City Point, from Baltimore, steam engine No. 4, for the purpose of forcing water from the James river to the hospital, a distance of one mile from the river. Some of the hospitals are located at such a distance from the river as to cause great difficulty in obtaining water for the patients. Several thousand feet of hose were also sent with the engine. Wesley Shaw, Assistant Engineer of the Baltimore Fire Department, Mike Donn, the engineer, and Jas Hall, the assistant engineer of No. 4, accompanied the engine.

You can read more about City Point at the Encyclopedia Virginia, including some information about its hospitals:

During the occupation, City Point was also home to the Depot Field Hospital, actually a group of hospitals serving the Second, Fifth, Sixth, and Ninth corps of the Army of the Potomac; a separate, affiliated hospital served the cavalry. Black Union troops were cared for in a segregated hospital until all United States Colored Troops in the Army of the Potomac were transferred to the Army of the James in December 1864. The sprawling hospital complex consisted of 1,200 tents in the summer of 1864, but these were soon replaced by 90 wooden buildings and 452 tents sufficient to house just more than 5,400 men. The hospital also had a water tower, kitchens, a dining hall, and an ice house. In 1865 alone, 29,000 patients were admitted, with 53 percent being transferred to hospitals farther north. Another 41 percent were returned to the front. Only 2 percent, or 572 patients, died while under care there.

At the US Army Quartermaster Foundation Captain Robert O. Zinnen, Jr. wrote about the hospitals in “City Point: The Tool That Gave General Grant Victory” and mentioned the water pumped from the James:

The medical care received by the wounded Union soldiers represented the finest in medical attention that that time period had to offer the sick or injured. Of the seven hospitals eventually located at City Point, the Depot Field Hospital was the largest and was able to provide care for 10,000 patients. Surgeon Edward B. Dalton commanded this tremendous operation of 1,200 tents, which blanketed 200 acres. As the weather cooled, 90 log buildings, 20 feet by 50 feet were built to house the wounded, but operations still required that 324 tents remain in use throughout the winter. Nurses ensured that each patient, who had his own bed and washbasin, was clean and comfortable by regularly providing clean linens and clothes.

These hospitals represented self-contained cities. They operated their own supply system very similar to the modern day network. The hospitals requisitioned, received and stored their own supplies. This system functioned so smoothly that the soldiers never lacked the necessary medicine or equipment. The hospitals ran their own laundries, dining facilities and dispensaries. These medical facilities even had running water, pumped from the James River, to assist in keeping the hospital as sanitary as possible under field conditions. These hospitals received vast amounts of assistance from civilian agencies such as the Christian Commission and the U.S. Sanitary Commission. These agencies provided fresh and canned fruit to help lift the health and morale of the soldiers. Each Corps had their own Sanitary Relief Station consisting of two wagons. These relief stations issued 100 tons of canned tomatoes, 1,200 barrels of cucumbers and 17,000 cans of Sauerkraut. The soldiers at City Point even had a lemonade stand to quench their thirst. Usually, two or three ships, loaded with goods supplied by these civilian commissions, sat at City Point waiting to unload their “treats.”

_____________________________________________

Meanwhile, at a different point along the James, the following photo of the U.S.S. Mendota was taken 150 years ago today while the ship was serving in the James River (Va.) Division, North Atlantic Blockading Squadron:

Bringing parrott gun into position on board gun boat "Mendota," July 10, 1864 (by Andrew J. Russell; LOC: LC-DIG-ppmsca-11714)

“Bringing parrott gun into position on board gun boat “Mendota,” July 10, 1864″

Posted in 150 Years Ago This Week, Military Matters, Siege of Petersburg | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment